Volume 07 Issue 04 April 2024
Rogers Barigayomwe, Ph.D.
Department of Development, Peace and Conflict Studies Kampala International University
DOI : https://doi.org/10.47191/ijsshr/v7-i04-10Google Scholar Download Pdf
ABSTRACT
When the Malabo Protocol was adopted in 2014, which, if ratified by at least 15 out of the 55 African Union (AU) Member States would lead to the creation of an African Criminal Court (ACC), it was received with great enthusiasm for a number of reasons. Notable among these were that the creation of the ACC would provide an avenue to address African challenges and crimes committed in the continent in an Africa way- echoing the notion of African solution to African problems. Yet, since it was adopted in June 2014 not even a single AU Member State has ratified the Malabo Protocol. Against this backdrop, the key question which this study seeks to answer is: What are the possible obstacles to the ratification of the Malabo Protocol and the inauguration of the ACC? The study reveals that there are seven primary possible obstacles to the ratification of the Malabo Protocol and inauguration of the ACC. These include: the contentious jurisdiction of the court, immunity for African Heads of State and senior government officials; the limited financial base which negatively affects the potential operationalization of the court; the contradictions and ambiguities regarding how the African Criminal Court will be operationalized
KEYWORDS:African Union, Malabo Protocol, African Criminal Court, International Criminal Court, Complementarity Principle.
REFERENCES1) Abass, A. (2013). The Proposed International Criminal Jurisdiction for the African Court: Some Problematical Aspects, Netherlands International Law Review 60, (27), 33–46.
2) Abass, A. (2013). Prosecuting International Crimes in Africa: Rationale, Prospects and Challenges, European Journal of International Law 24(3), 933–946
3) Abraham, G. (2015). Africa’s Evolving Continental Court Structures: At the Crossroads? South African Institute of International Affairs (SAIIA), Occasional Paper 209. Available online at: www.saiia.org.za/cat_view/2-occasionalpapers?dir=DESC&limit=10&order=name&start=220 (Accessed 02 February 2020).
4) Adjami, M. and Mushiata, G. (2010) Democratic Republic of Congo: Impact of the Rome Statute and the International Criminal Court, ICJT Briefing, The Rome Statute Review Conference, Kampala, 2010. Available at:
5) Akande, D. (2003). The Jurisdiction of International Criminal Court over Nationals of Non-Parties: Legal Basis and Limits, Journal of International Criminal Justice 1(3), 618-650.
6) Amnesty International. (2017, p.11). Malabo Protocol: Legal and Institutional Implications of the Merged and Expanded African Court Snapshots. Available at. https://www.amnesty.org/download/Documents/AFR0161372017ENGLISH.PDF(Accesed 19 August 2021).
7) Appel, B. J. (2018). In the Shadow of the International Criminal Court: Does the ICC Deter Human Rights Violations? Journal of Conflict Resolution 62(1), 3-28
8) Bekou, O. (2013). Complementarity Principle. Oxford Biographies. Available at. https://www.oxfordbibliographies.com/view/document/obo-9780199796953/obo-9780199796953-0071.xml (accessed 12/03/2019).
9) Clarke, K. M. (2015). Refiguring the Perpetrator: Culpability, History and International Criminal Law’s Impunity Gap. The International Journal of Human Rights 19, 592-614.
10) Clarke, K. M. (2010). Ethics of Scale: Relocating Politics after Liberation. Rethinking Africa thought its Exclusions: The Politics of Naming Criminal Responsibility. Anthropological Quarterly 83, 625-652.
11) Clark, N. J. (2011). Peace, Justice and the International Criminal Court: Possibilities and Limitations, Journal of International Criminal Justice 9(3), 521-545.
12) Clarke, K. M.; Jalloh, C. C. and Nmehielle, V. O. (2019). The African Court of Justice and Human and Peoples' Rights in Context. Development and Challenges. New York: Cambridge University Press.
13) Deya, D. (2012). Worth the Wait: Pushing for the African Court to Exercise Jurisdiction for International Crimes, Open Society Initiative for Southern Africa (OSISA). Available at: www.osisa.org/openspace/regional/african-court-worth-wait (Accessed 14 February 2020).
14) Drumbl, M. (2007). Atrocity, Punishment, and International Law. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
15) Du Plessis, M. (2012). Implications of the AU decision to give the African Court jurisdiction over international crimes, Institute for Security Studies (ISS), ISS Paper 235. Available at: www.issafrica.org/publications/papers/implications-of-the-au-decision-to-give-the-african-court-jurisdiction-over-international-crimes (Accessed 14 February 2020).
16) Du Plessis, M.; Louw, A. and Maunganidze, O. A. (2012). African Efforts to Close the Impunity Gap: Lessons for Complementarity from National and Regional Actions. Available at. https://www.africaportal.org/publications/african-efforts-to-close-the-impunity-gap-lessons-for-complementarity-from-national-and-regional-actions/ (Accessed 12, May 2020).
17) Gegout, C. (2013). The International Criminal Court: limits, potential and conditions for the promotion of justice and peace, Third World Quarterly 34 (5), 800-818.
18) Grovogui, S. (2015). Intricate Entanglement: The International Criminal Court and the Pursuit of Peace, Reconciliation and Justice in Libya, Guinea, and Mali”. Africa Development 2, 99- 122
19) Holmes, J. T. (2001). “Jurisdiction and Admissibility”, in Lee (eds.), International Criminal Court: Elements of Crimes & Rules of Procedure. Ardsley: Transnational Publishers, pp. 321-348.
20) Imoedemhe, O. (2015). ‘Unpacking the Tension Between the African Union and the International Criminal Court: The Way Forward’, African Journal of International and Comparative Law 23(1), 74-105.
21) Jalloh, C. C. (2017). The Nature of the Crimes in the African Criminal Court, Journal of International Criminal Justice 15(4), 799–826
22) Jalloh, C. C.; Clarke, K. M. and Nmehielle, V. O. (2019). The African Court of Justice and Human and Peoples' Rights in Context Development and Challenges, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
23) Johnson, C. (2017). African Union: Resolution Urges States to Leave ICC, Global Legal Monitor. Available at. https://www.loc.gov/law/foreign-news/article/african-union-resolution-urges-states-to-leave-icc/(Accessed 24 September 2021).
24) Ku, J., and Nzelibe, J. (2006). Do International Criminal Tribunals Deter or Exacerbate Atrocities? Washington University Law Review 84, 777-833.
25) Mahdi, M. (2019). Africa’s International Crimes Court is Still a Pipe Dream. Transnational Threats and International Crime News and Press Release. Pretoria: Institute for Security Studies.
26) Mangu, A. M. (2014). The African Union and the Promotion of Democracy and Good Political Governance Under the African Peer-Review Mechanism: 10 years on. Africa Review 6(1), 59-72.
27) Murithi, T. (2013). ‘The African Union and the International Criminal Court: An Embattled Relationship?’ The Institute for Justice and Reconciliation, Policy Brief No. 8.
28) Mwangi, K. S. (2013). ‘Can the International Criminal Court Play Fair in Africa?’ Africa in Focus, The Brookings Institute. Available at:
29) Mystris, D. (2019). Why a Regional Criminal Court for Africa is a Good Idea. Available at: https://theconversation.com/why-a-regional-criminal-court-for-africa-is-a-good-idea-123650(Accessed20February 2020).
30) Nmehielle, V. O. (2014). “Saddling” the New African Regional Human Rights Court with International Criminal Jurisdiction: Innovative, Obstructive, And Expedient? African Journal of Legal Studies 7, 7-42.
31) Nissel, A. (2004). Continuing Crimes in the Rome Statute. Michigan Journal of International Law 25, 653-689.
32) Rau, K. (2012). Jurisprudential Innovation or Accountability Avoidance? The International Criminal Court and Proposed Expansion of the African Court of Justice and Human Rights, Minnesota Law Review 97, 669-708
33) Rodriguez, J. B. C. (2019). The proposed African criminal chamber: an effective tool to end impunity on African soil? Revista Electrónica Cordobesa de Derecho Internacional Público (RECorDIP) 1. Available at. file:///C:/Users/admin/Downloads/24992-Texto%20del%20art%C3%ADculo-73182-1-10-20190722.pdf (20February 2020).
34) Sirleaf, M. (2016). The African Justice Cascade and the Malabo Protocol, International Journal of Transitional Justice 11(1), 1-35
35) Syenyonjo, M. (2013). ‘The Rise of the African Union Opposition to the International Criminal Court’s Investigations and Prosecutions of African Leaders’, International Criminal Court Review13(2), 385-428.
36) Tiba, F. K. (2016). Regional International Criminal Courts: An Idea Whose Time Has Come? Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution 17, 521- 549.
37) Tjitske L. (2019). Welcome to the ICC “Facts and Figures. “Available at: https://www.justiceinfo.net/en/tribunals/icc/41532-welcome-to-the-icc-facts-and-figures.html, (Accessed: 20 December 2021).
38) Tladi, D. (2015). The Immunity Provision in the AU Amendment Protocol, Journal of International Criminal Justice 13, 3–17.
39) Van der Merwe, B. (2014). International Criminal Justice in Africa Challenges and Opportunities, Nairobi: Lino Typesetters (K) LTD
40) Van der Wilt, H. (2016). Expanding Criminal Responsibility in Transnational and International Organised Crime, Groningen Journal of International Law 4(1), 1-9.