Volume 08 Issue 04 April 2025
Yaron Katz
Holon Institute of Technology, Israel
DOI : https://doi.org/10.47191/ijsshr/v8-i4-34Google Scholar Download Pdf
ABSTRACT
The war in the Middle East has intensified the longstanding debate over the conscription of Haredi (ultra-Orthodox) men into the Israel Defense Forces (IDF). For decades, ultra-Orthodox communities have been largely exempt from military service, instead focusing on religious studies, a policy that has become increasingly contentious as the Haredi population grows. The evolving relationship between Israeli society and the IDF indicates broader social transformations within the country. The rise of liberal ideologies raises important questions about the future of the citizen-soldier model and its implications for national security. The war has underscored the need for a unified defense strategy, challenging the existing social contract between the state and ultra-Orthodox communities. As Israeli society struggles with these tensions, the need for a dialogue that bridges ideological divides becomes increasingly critical for fostering a cohesive national identity capable of addressing internal and external challenges. This paper examines how the military conflict has heightened the national conversation around equitable burden-sharing, with many Israelis advocating for including Haredi men in national defense efforts. This paper explores the potential implications of the war on future policies regarding military conscription, assessing whether the current conflict may lead to significant shifts in Israeli society and governance.
KEYWORDS:Middle East Conflict; National Defense; ultra-Orthodox; military conscription; Intersectionality
REFERENCES1) Allison, R. (2011). Race, Gender, and Attitudes Toward War in Chicago: An Intersectional Analysis. Sociological Forum, 26(3), 668-691
2) Ben-Ari, E. (2023). Resisting the Draft: The Ultra-Orthodox Community and the Military. Israel Defense Review, 15(1), 10–25.
3) Ben-Porat, G. (2013). Social Cohesion and the Challenge of Divided Societies. International Journal of Social Welfare, 22(1), 32–42.
4) Ben-Porat, G. (2023). Conflict, Religion, and Politics in Israel: The Role of the Ultra-Orthodox. Middle East Journal, 75(2), 183–201.
5) Ben-Shalom, U., Babis, D., Sabar, G. et al. Experiences, Identity, and Adaptation Among Children of Migrant Laborers in Compulsory Military Service in the Israel Defense Forces. Int. Migration & Integration 24, 773–791.
6) Cohen, E. (2010). The Israeli Military: A Model of Democracy? Journal of Military Ethics, 9(2), 160–175.
7) Cohen, E. (2023). Political instability in Israel over the last decades – Causes and consequences. Cogent Social Sciences, 10(1).
8) Cohen, A., & Kizel, A. (2022). The Political Dynamics of Ultra-Orthodox Parties in Israeli Governance: From Sectarianism to National Responsibility. Israel Affairs, 28(1), 37–55.
9) Choshen, R. (2023). Protests and Politics: The Ultra-Orthodox Community's Response to Social Movements in Israel. Journal of Israeli Studies, 29(2), 120–135.
10) Cooper, L., Caddick, N., Godier, L., Cooper, A., & Fossey, M. (2018). Transition From the Military Into Civilian Life: An Exploration of Cultural Competence. Armed Forces & Society, 44(1), 156-177.
11) Crenshaw, K. (1989). Demarginalizing the Intersection of Race and Sex: A Black Feminist Critique of Antidiscrimination Doctrine, Feminist Theory and Antiracist Politics. University of Chicago Legal Forum, 1989(1), 139–167.
12) Crenshaw, K. (1991). Mapping the Margins: Intersectionality, Identity Politics, and Violence against Women of Color. Stanford Law Review, 43(6), 1241–1299.
13) Friedman, M. (2022). Identity and Service: The Haredi Youth Experience in the IDF. Sociology of Religion, 84(2), 189–206.
14) Golan, O. (2022). Mobilizing the Haredi Community: Media, Identity, and Political Engagement. Israel Affairs, 28(4), 603–620.
15) Hankivsky, O. (2014). Intersectionality 101. Institute for Intersectionality Research and Policy, Simon Fraser University.
16) Harel, A. (2020). Economic Inequality and the Ultra-Orthodox Community in Israel: A Study of Social Mobility and Identity. Journal of Jewish Studies, 65(2), 150–175.
17) Harel, A. (2024). Refusal to serve in the Israel Defense Forces reserves in an era of anti-democratic judicial reform. Critical Military Studies, pp. 1–6.
18) Hoffman, E. (2019). The Ultra-Orthodox in Israel: Identity and Military Service. Contemporary Jewry, 39(3), 305–322.
19) Hoffman, S. (2024). National Security in Crisis: The Implications of Social Protest on the IDF. Security Studies, 33(1), 88–105.
20) Israel Policy Forum (2024). The Haredi Exemption. https://israelpolicyforum.org/2024/06/25/the-haredi-exemption/
21) Kingsley, P. (2024). As World's Gaze Shifts to Gaza, Israel's Psyche Remains Defined by Oct. 7 Attack. International New YorkTimes. https://go.gale.com/ps/i.do?id=GALE%7CA777652731&sid=googleScholar&v=2.1&it=r&linkaccess=abs&issn=22699740&p=AONE&sw=w
&userGroupName=anon%7E3af7b1cb&aty=open-web-entry
22) Koppel, M. (2021). Public Opinion on Military Service in Israel: A Case Study of the Haredim. Israel Studies Review, 36(4), 72–90.
23) Levy, D., & Michal, Y. (2021). Intersectionality and Identity Politics in the Context of Israeli Society: Implications for Ultra-Orthodox Communities. Journal of Israeli History, 40(2), 123-141.
24) Liebman, C. S., & Don-Yehiya, E. (2020). Religion and State in Israel: A Changing Paradigm. The Jewish Quarterly Review, 110(3-4), pp. 432–456.
25) Lipkind, S. (2024). Why Israel Wants to Draft the Ultra-Orthodox Into the Military. Council on Foreign Relations. https://www.cfr.org/in-brief/why-israel-wants-draft-ultra-orthodox-military
26) Malach, G., Cahaner, L., & Mansfeld, A. (2022). Poverty Among Ultra-Orthodox Families: Causes and Implications. Israel Economic Review, 29(3), 241-260.
27) Maoz, K. (2024). Social Dissent and Identity in Ultra-Orthodox Israel: Navigating Modernity and Tradition. Contemporary Jewry, 44(1), 67–82.
28) McKinzie, A. E; and Richards, P. L (2019). An argument for context-driven intersectionality. Sociology Compass. 13(4).
29) Nash, J. C. (2008). Re-Thinking Intersectionality. Feminist Review, 89(1), 1–15. https://doi.org/10.1057/fr.2008.4
30) Neuberger, B. (2020). Israel’s unstable democracy in comparative perspective. Israel Affairs, 26(6), 833–853.
31) Nisbet, E. (2020). Ultra-Orthodox Media and the Politics of Resistance: A Study of Haredi Narratives in Israeli Society. Journal of Jewish Studies, 72(1), 105–120.
32) Ravitzky, A. (2013). The Haredim in the IDF: A Complex Relationship. Israel Affairs, 19(3), 383–402.
33) Sasson-Levy, O. (2005). CONSTRUCTING IDENTITIES AT THE MARGINS: Masculinities and Citizenship in the Israeli Army. The Sociological Quarterly. 43(3). 357-383.
34) Shafir, G., & Peled, Y. (2002). Being Israeli: The Dynamics of Multiple Nationalisms. In Nation and Nationalism, 8(4), 433–455.
35) Shahak, M. (2019). The Role of Military Exemptions in the Haredi Community: Historical Perspectives. Israel Journal of Political Science, 18(1), 55–70.
36) Smooha, S. (2002). Arab-Jewish Relations in Israel: The Challenge of a Multicultural Society. Middle Eastern Studies, 38(4), 1–20.
37) Sullivan, J. (2021). The Politics of Exemption: The Ultra-Orthodox Community and Military Service in Israel. Middle Eastern Studies, 57(5), 743–760.
38) Yadgar, Y. (2021). The Haredi Community in a Changing Society: Media Influence and Cultural Resilience. Contemporary Jewry, 41(2), 230–245.
39) Yavetz, G., Cohen, T., & Zamir, L. (2024). The dual use of social media by Naftali Bennett during his brief premiership: a double-edged sword? Israel Affairs, 30(2), 249–263
40) Yishai, Y. (2008). Political Polarization and Democracy in Israel. Journal of Democracy, 19(1), 62–76.
41) Zerubavel, Y. (2022). Liberalism and Identity Politics in Israeli Society: Implications for the Ultra-Orthodox Community. Journal of Political Ideologies, 27(4), 312-329.
42) Ziv, G. (2024). Civil-Military Relations in the Age of Populist Nationalism: The Case of Israel, Political Science Quarterly, 139(1), 1–20